Current evidence is insufficient to answer the question of whether supervised hand therapy leads to different outcomes as compared to an independent home exercise program following surgical or non-surgical treatment of a distal radius fracture (DRF). There were only a few studies that met the inclusion criteria and even those had some important shortcomings. After expanding the number of studies, issues with the experiments included risk of bias, lack of homogeneity regarding injury severity, variable ages, and low prevalence of post-fracture complications. One high (Gutierrez Espinoza et al, 2017) and six moderate quality studies (Valdes et al, 2015; Souer et al, 2011; Oken et al. 2011; Krischak et al, 2009; Maciel et al. 2005; Wakefield et al, 2000) were included and appraised. One found a benefit to supervised therapy 3 weeks after injury or surgery (Oken et al. 2011), and one (Gutierrez Espinoza et al, 2017) at 6 weeks and at 6 months. In contrast, one study (Krischak et al, 2009) favored independent exercises at 6 weeks, and 4 found no difference between supervised and independent exercises (Valdes et al, 2015; Souer et al, 2011; Maciel et al. 2005; Wakefield et al, 2000).
Risks and Benefits of Implementation
It is possible that a subset of people recovering from distal radius fractures might benefit from supervised hand therapy, and experience more rapid return to function with decreased total societal costs. For those that independent exercises are sufficient, we can preserve health care resources and minimize cost and time burden for patients recovering from distal radius fractures through independent exercises.
Outcome Importance
A rule prohibiting supervised therapy after distal radius fractures might limit access for a subset of people who stand to benefit. We might conclude that—to date--routine supervised hand therapy does not seem to provide a benefit on average.
Cost Effectiveness/Resource Utilization
We currently lack sufficient evidence to determine if there are circumstances in which supervised therapy limits patient and societal costs.
Acceptability
There is a risk that surgeons might feel this statement restricts their ability to ask for help from expert colleagues when a patient’s recovery from distal radius fractures is delayed or difficult. There is a risk
that hand therapists will feel the summary of the evidence undervalues their contributions to the recovery of some people recovering from distal radius fractures.
Feasibility
Implementation of this summary is feasible to the extent that it does not become an all or none policy and that we continue to investigate factors that facilitate recovery and utilize supervised hand therapy for those subset(s) of patients where clinical benefit can be demonstrated.
Future Research
More and better evidence is needed to determine when supervised hand therapy benefits people recovering from DRF. Most importantly, further research is needed to determine prognostic criteria that would allow for proper patient selection. Thus, research should be invested in establishing a classification system for DRF patients sub-categorization based on their rehabilitation needs, while considering all contextual factors that may limit their recovery potential.
- Gutierrez-Espinoza, H., Rubio-Oyarzun, D., Olguin-Huerta, C., Gutierrez-Monclus, R., Pinto-Concha, S., Gana-Hervias, G. Supervised physical therapy vs home exercise program for patients with distal radius fracture: A single-blind randomized clinical study. Journal of Hand Therapy 2017; 3: 242-252
- Valdes, K., Naughton, N., Burke, C. J. Therapist-supervised hand therapy versus home therapy with therapist instruction following distal radius fracture. Journal of Hand Surgery - American Volume 2015; 6: 1110-6.e1
- Souer, J. S., Buijze, G., Ring, D. A prospective randomized controlled trial comparing occupational therapy with independent exercises after volar plate fixation of a fracture of the distal part of the radius. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery - American Volume 2011; 19: 1761-6
- Oken, O., Ceceli, E., Oken, F. O., Yorgancioglu, R. Z. Hospital-based versus home-based program in rehabilitation of distal radius fractures. Turkiye Fiziksel Tip ve Rehabilitasyon Dergisi 2011; 3: 139-142
- Krischak, G. D., Krasteva, A., Schneider, F., Gulkin, D., Gebhard, F., Kramer, M. Physiotherapy after volar plating of wrist fractures is effective using a home exercise program. Archives of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation 2009; 4: 537-44
- Maciel, J. S., Taylor, N. F., McIlveen, C. A randomised clinical trial of activity-focussed physiotherapy on patients with distal radius fractures. Archives of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery 2005; 8: 515-20
- Wakefield, A. E., McQueen, M. M. The role of physiotherapy and clinical predictors of outcome after fracture of the distal radius. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery - British Volume 2000; 7: 972-6